Whether you need to protect a successful trial court result or obtain the reversal of an adverse judgment, Aronberg Goldgehn's appellate attorneys are well-equipped to provide representation of the highest quality throughout the appellate process.
Our appellate practice is made up of attorneys who take the success of your appeal personally. Our lawyers include former law clerks to appellate justices and professors of Appellate Advocacy who have extensive experience in the federal courts of appeal and state appellate and supreme courts.
Our appellate practice embraces a wide array of cases, and we possess the skill and experience necessary to master any substantive area of law, however complex or nuanced. We have handled appeals involving issues of:
- Banking law
- Civil procedure
- Constitutional law
- Contract interpretation
- Criminal law
- Employment law
- Family law
- Insurance Coverage
- Personal injury law
- Real estate law
- Court-imposed sanctions
- Unfair competition
Cost-effective representation is the primary goal of our appellate group. At the outset, we provide candid and objective advice to clients on the crucial question of whether or not to pursue an appeal. Depending on the nature of the case, we also explore with clients alternative billing arrangements.
MBK Services, Inc. v. Cole Taylor Bank, et al
No. 12-3026 (Il. 1st Dist. Sept. 26, 2013)
The Illinois Appellate Court affirmed the trial court’s granting of the lender’s motion for summary judgment, finding that a bank’s perfected security interest in the borrower’s collateral, including the proceeds of a sale of a borrower’s assets after an assignment for the benefit creditors, is superior to a business creditor’s claim to such proceeds, even if such proceeds were “supposed” to be held in trust by the borrower.
O'Hare Ground Transport Facility v. FirstMerit Bank, et al
2013 IL App (1st) 121428-U
The court affirmed the trial court’s rulings that defendant bank was not responsible to pay $1,000,000.00 for uncollateralized letters of credit issued by the failed predecessor bank. The court held that the purchase and assumption agreement governing the FDIC’s take-over did not provide that the successor bank would assume liability for letters of credit.
Trustees of the Electricians' Salary Deferral Plan, et al. v. Pamela Wright
No. 11-2051 (U.S. 8th Cir., August 21, 2012)
We prevailed on a competing claim for ERISA benefits, which a deceased electrical worker had intended to leave to his cousin. Another relative of the deceased claimed that the deceased was not of sound mind when he changed the beneficiary on his pension plan to his cousin. The case was initially filed with the pension plan administrator, then to the pension plan’s appeals committee. From there, it was filed in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri, where we obtained summary judgment for our client. On appeal to the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, the Eighth Circuit affirmed the District Court’s decision, allowing our client to obtain the benefits of the plan.
St. Paul Fire & Marine Ins. Co. v. E.R.A. Oxford
572 F.3d 893 (11th Cir. 2009)
In a significant decision involving "professional services" coverage provided under a real estate professional errors and omissions insurance policy, the court reversed the trial court's summary judgment in favor of a real estate broker and directed the trial court to enter summary judgment for the insurer. The court held that the broker's conduct in connection with aborted business mergers was not part of the broker's "professional services" and therefore was not within the policy's coverage.
Farmers Ins. Co. v. St. Paul Mercury Ins. Co.
482 F.3d 976 (7th Cir. 2007)
The court affirmed the District Court's summary judgment in favor of the defendant employment practices liability insurer, finding that claims against the plaintiff employer for violations of the Illinois Minimum Wage Act were not covered under the insurance policy.
Trippe Mfg. Co. v. Niles Audio Corp.
401 F.3d 529 (3rd Cir. 2005)
The Court reversed the District Court’s decision compelling the Plaintiff to arbitrate the Defendant’s multi-million dollar successor-liability claims in arbitration. The Court held that the Plaintiff had not assumed responsibility for the Defendant’s claims and thus was not bound to arbitrate them.
Methode Electronics, Inc. v. Adam Technologies, Inc.
371 F.3d 923 (7th Cir. 2004)
The Court, based on a legal theory that was not raised by trial counsel, affirmed the District Court’s imposition of sanctions against Plaintiff.
Neuma, Inc. v. AMP, Inc.
259 F.3d 864 (7th Cir. 2001)
The Court reversed the District Court’s decision dismissing the Plaintiff’s ERISA and negligent misrepresentation claims.
Traveler's Ins. Co. v. Eljer Mfg., Inc.
197 Ill. 2d 278 (2001)
The Supreme Court held that the mere installation of a defective plumbing system did not, within the meaning of a comprehensive general liability insurance policy, constitute “physical injury to tangible property” unless and until the system leaked. This decision expressly overruled an Illinois Appellate Court decision that had been the law in Illinois for more than a decade.
Williams v. Hall
288 Ill. App. 3d 917 (1st Dist. 1997)
In this wrongful death action, the Court affirmed the trial court’s setting aside of a $1 million verdict in favor of the Plaintiff. The Court held that the Defendant’s employee was acting outside the scope of his employment at the time of the accident in question and, therefore, the Defendant could not be held vicariously liable for its employee’s conduct.
Saunders v. Michigan Ave. Nat'l Bank
278 Ill. App. 3d 307 (1st Dist. 1996)
In this frequently-cited opinion, the Court affirmed the trial court’s dismissal of the Plaintiff’s Complaint for, among other things violation of the Illinois Consumer Fraud Act.
Elmer Miller, Inc. v. Landis
253 Ill. App. 3d 129 (1st Dist. 1993)
The Court affirmed the trial court’s entry of a preliminary injunction against the Defendant, holding that the Plaintiff had established that its customer list constituted a trade secret within the meaning of the Illinois Trade Secrets Act.
Aronberg Goldgehn Members Amy M. Gibson, Kari E. Kaplan and Mary V. Hays have been listed in Crain’s Custom Media’s inaugural edition of The Most Influential Women Lawyers in Chicago.... Read More
Nineteen of the firm’s members have been named Leading Lawyers by Illinois Leading Lawyers, a designation awarded to less than 5 percent of Illinois attorneys.... Read More
Katie Attebery, Amy Gibson, Julie Johnson, Kari Kaplan, Tim Nelson, Amber LaFevers and Sara Spratt have been named Emerging Lawyers by Illinois Leading Lawyers, a designation awarded to less than 2 percent of Illinois attorneys.... Read More
Aronberg Goldgehn member Julie A. Johnson has been selected as the recipient of the 2017 Alta May Hulett Award. She will receive the award at a luncheon ceremony on May 24, 2017.... Read More
Aronberg Goldgehn attorneys Lawrence Stein and Benjamin Haskin will present “Admitting Complex Electronic Materials into Evidence” at the Du Page County Courthouse on March 10.... Read More
Staci L. Balbirer, Amy M. Gibson, Julie A. Johnson, Kari E. Hoelting Kaplan, Amber O. LaFevers and Timothy R. Nelson have been named “Rising Stars” by Illinois Super Lawyers.... Read More
Aronberg Goldgehn members Chris Bannon, Jay Frank, Tom Hanekamp, Blooma Stark, Larry Stein and Michael Zaslavsky have been selected as Illinois Super Lawyers for 2017.... Read More
Aronberg Goldgehn Davis & Garmisa has named Julie A. Johnson (formerly Neubauer) as a Member of the firm.... Read More
Aronberg Goldgehn member Larry Stein is also a member of the committee hosting the reception on September 26, 2016.... Read More
Aronberg Goldgehn is honored to be the Northern Illinois University Fellowship Sponsor for the Illinois Bar Foundation’s 2016 Gala, where Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan will be presented with the 2016 Distinguished Award for Excellence.... Read More
Aronberg Goldgehn member Lawrence A. Stein has been appointed to the Board of Directors of the Illinois Bar Foundation.... Read More
Litigator John C. Sciaccotta has been elected a Member of the prestigious Federation of Defense & Corporate Counsel.... Read More
Ulta Beauty General Counsel Jodi Caro Honored With the 2016 Inspiration Award... Read More
Aronberg Goldgehn litigation attorneys Nathan H. Lichtenstein and Benjamin E. Haskin have obtained a victory in the Illinois Appellate Court.... Read More
Aronberg attorneys Nathan Lichtenstein and Benjamin Haskin's victory for a bank client is featured in the May 31 edition of the Chicago Daily Law Bulletin.... Read More
Trial lawyer Nathan Lichtenstein and his fellow panelists will present “Tips & Techniques to Defend Your Position.”... Read More
Lawrence A. Stein has been appointed a member of the ISBA’s Standing Committee on Legal Education Admission & Competence and its Federal Civil Practice Section Council.... Read More
Lawrence A. Stein has published a note in The Brief on the recent order by the Supreme Court of Illinois mandating that all Illinois courts implement systems to permit the electronic filing of materials in civil cases.... Read More
On Jan. 29, Lawrence A. Stein will co-present “Dealing with and Counseling Clients Regarding Business Interests in Contested Estates.”... Read More
Lawrence A. Stein has joined Aronberg Goldgehn Davis & Garmisa as a member, adding considerable depth and experience to the firm’s appellate and litigation practices.... Read More
American Access Casualty Co. v. Alassouli reaffirms the difficult standard insurers must meet in Illinois when disclaiming coverage based on the breach of a policy’s cooperation clause.... Read More
Nate Lichtenstein and Amy Rapoport Gibson Will Lead the Commercial Litigation Group; Paul Gilman and Tim Nelson, Business Law & Transactions... Read More
Aronberg Goldgehn Co-Managing Member Christopher J. Bannon and others address what firms can do to ensure that female attorneys’ compensation and opportunities keep pace with their talent and commitment.... Read More
Chicago Lawyer magazine’ has published the results of its annual diversity survey of the largest law firms in Illinois, and Aronberg Goldgehn has been ranked No. 1 in one analysis of the statistics.... Read More
On May 7, 2015, Aronberg Goldgehn Co-Managing Member Christopher J. Bannon and his fellow panelists will present "Rising Above the Stats: Defining and Encouraging Success for Women Attorneys and Methods for Achieving It."... Read More
Presented by the ISBA Standing Committee on Women and the Law, this CLE program will address issues facing women lawyers.... Read More
In a much-anticipated decision that impacts liability insurers’ ability to obtain policy rescission, the Illinois Supreme Court ruled on February 20, 2015 that the “innocent insured” doctrine does not apply to rescission cases.... Read More
Christopher J. Bannon, Jay A. Frank and Blooma Stark have been selected as Illinois ‘Super Lawyers;’ Kari E. Hoelting Kaplan, Amber N. LaFevers, Timothy R. Nelson and Amy M. Rapoport Gibson named ‘Rising Stars.’... Read More
Aronberg Goldgehn has elected Lisa J. Brodsky, Timothy R. Nelson and Amy M. Rapoport Gibson as Members of the firm, effective January 1, 2015.... Read More
Aronberg Goldgehn litigators Nathan H. Lichtenstein and Benjamin Haskin obtained the rare feat of directed finding to secure a trial victory for a long-time client.... Read More
Amy Rapoport Gibson will present at the May meeting of the Association of Corporate Counsel on Winning the “Battle of the Forms”... Read More
Kari E. Hoelting Kaplan, Amber LaFevers, Timothy R. Nelson and Amy M. Rapoport Gibson have been designated as Rising Stars by Illinois Super Lawyers.... Read More
Christopher J. Bannon, Jay A. Frank, William J. Garmisa and Blooma Stark have been selected as Super Lawyers by Illinois Super Lawyers.... Read More
Aronberg Goldgehn members Christopher J. Bannon, Jay A. Frank, William J. Garmisa and Blooma Stark have been selected as Illinois Super Lawyers.... Read More
Aronberg Attorneys Katherine A. Attebery, Amy M. Rapoport Gibson, Timothy R. Nelson and Julie A. Neubauer and have been designated Rising Stars in Illinois by Super Lawyers.... Read More
The Illinois Appellate Court held that an insurer breached its duty to defend when it hired defense counsel but did not take sufficient action to ensure that counsel provided an “actual defense” for the insured. Consequently the court found the insurer liable for damages in an amount well in excess of the policy limits.... Read More
Aronberg Goldgehn is pleased to announce that four attorneys were selected as Illinois ‘Super Lawyers’ for 2013 and four attorneys were designated as ‘Rising Stars’ in Illinois by Super Lawyers magazine.... Read More
Aronberg Goldgehn litigators Lisa J. Brodsky and Amy M. Rapoport Gibson have obtained an appellate court victory before the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit in IBEW Pension Plan v Wright and Walker.... Read More
Christopher Bannon has obtained an appellate court victory for a professional liability insurer in a Louisiana suit over insurance coverage for an accountant accused of securities laws violations and related wrongful acts.... Read More